Don’t Meddle With The Supreme Court, Says Justice Samuel Alito To Congress


Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito, who has been at the center of a number of ethics controversies at the court recently, told the Wall Street Journal lawmakers need to give up on the idea of imposing new rules on the justices.

“No provision in the Constitution gives them the authority to regulate the Supreme Court — period,” he told a pair of interviewers for the business paper’s Opinion section in a piece that appeared Friday.

Alito, who authored the opinion in the Dobbs case that overturned Roe v. Wade, has been unusually active for a sitting federal judge in fending off claims of impropriety.

He went so far as getting the Journal to publish an op-ed he wrote defending himself against claims in a ProPublica story he had failed to disclose a gifted luxury trip and private jet travel — before ProPublica had even published the story.

In the interview published Friday, Alito said ordinarily, “the organized bar” of lawyers would defend the court against its critics. But he said that hasn’t been happening, “And, so at a certain point I’ve said to myself, nobody else is going to do this, so I have to defend myself.”

There’s been a lot to defend lately, as Alito and fellow conservative Justice Clarence Thomas have been accused of failing to properly report gifts on federal disclosure forms. Thomas, in particular, was reported by ProPublica to have accepted trips from Republican megadonor Harlan Crow for years.

The ethics disputes led Senate Democrats to consider requiring the Court to stick to stricter ethics standards, closer to those seen in the congressional and executive branches of the government.

On July 20, the Senate Judiciary Committee approved a bill by Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse (D-R.I.) that would require the Supreme Court to adopt a code of conduct and create a process to investigate potential breaches.

Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse (D-R.I.) has been pushing the U.S. Supreme Court to adhere to stricter ethics standards in the wake of scandals about justices receiving lavish trips from people linked to cases before the court or big-time political donors.

Chief Justice John Roberts has said such changes aren’t needed, and the court could be trusted to self-regulate. But Alito’s comments appear to go much further, saying Congress cannot impose any requirements on the Supreme Court because it is part of an equal branch of government created by the U.S. Constitution.

Congress already controls one big aspect of the Supreme Court by setting how much it can spend annually, and the Constitution also notes its jurisdiction as a court of appeals is subject to “such regulations as the Congress may make.”

Whitehouse, in a post on social media, said one of two interviewers, who wrote that they sat with Alito for four hours in total over two sessions ending in early July, is part of an effort to block an investigation into Leonard Leo, co-chairman of the libertarian Federalist Society that has been influential in picking GOP nominees to the courts.

News site TPM said that lawyer David Rivkin regularly writes for the Opinion section but is also part of a team with law firm BakerHostetler LLP that has a big taxation case set to come before the court that could decide whether a wealth tax would be constitutional.

Whitehouse posted, “Shows how small and shallow the pool of operatives is around this captured Court — same folks keep popping up wearing new hats.”



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

8 Times Amy Jackson Took The Internet By Storm With Her Glamorous Avatar February 14, 2024 Here Are Best Anime Couples Of All Time – Koimoi Keerthy Suresh Exudes Elegance In A Timeless Yellow Saree February 1, 2024 Madhuri Dixit Steals Hearts In A Blue Saree February 3, 2024 8 Unknown Facts About Controversial Actress-model Poonam Pandey February 5, 2024 Sruthi Haasan Raises Glam Quotient In A Green Printed Co-ord Set February 5, 2024 8 Times Kriti Sanon Made Heads Turn In Stylish Outfits February 6, 2024 Alaya F Looks Smoking Hot In Silver Bodycon Dress February 7, 2024 Janhvi Kapoor Turns Heads In A Ravishing Red Dress February 8, 2024 Priyamani Looks Every Bit Of An Ethnic Diva In Royal Blue Striped Silk Saree February 9, 2024 Deepti Sati's Glamorous Lehenga Looks February 10, 2024 Netflix’s Global Top 10 Films: From Lift To The Super Mario Bros Movie, See The Full List! – Koimoi Must Watch Top 10 Anime High School Romcoms – Koimoi What To Watch On HBO And Max In February 2024 – Koimoi Top 7 Grinch Movies And TV Shows To Watch This Christmas Season – Complete Details Inside! – Koimoi Complete Guide To Watch Every Godzilla Movie In The Monsterverse — With Release And Chronological Order – Koimoi Top 5 Underrated Horror Anime Series – Koimoi Best Shoujo Romance Anime of All Time — You’re Not Ready for These – Koimoi Highest-Grossing Anime Movies: From Your Name, Demon Slayer & The First Slam Dunk – Films That Managed To Redefine Animated Cinema! – Koimoi 5 Best Black Anime Characters In Most Impactful And Trailblazing Anime – Koimoi